xREL.v3

Boring. Australian/American. Television (BATV) - Presents...

Release Name.....: Looking.S02E09.PROPER.720p.HDTV.x264-BATV
Release Date.....: 2015-03-16
Release Size.....: 834 MiB
Release Archives.: 18*50
Release CRF......: 18
Release Preset...: slow
Duration.........: 00:28:51.776
Frame Rate.......: 23.976
Resolution.......: 1280x720
Aspect Ratio.....: 16:9
Video Codec......: H.264
Video Bitrate....: 3573 Kbps
Audio Codec......: AC-3
Audio Bitrate....: 384 Kbps
Audio Channels...: 2
Notes............: *Sigh* Wow....

[NUKE] Girls.S04E09.720p.HDTV.x264-IMMERSE [missing.credits.that.contain.unique.music.continuation.from.end.of.episode_get.KILLERS.proper] [LocalNet]
[NUKE] Girls.S04E09.HDTV.x264-ASAP [missing.credits.that.contain.unique.music.continuation.from.end.of.episode_get.KILLERS.proper] [LocalNet]
[NUKE] Girls.S04E09.PROPER.HDTV.x264-KILLERS [invalid.proper_credits.are.optional.per.ruleset_no.missing.dialog_i.imgur.com.bXDjGSO.jpg] [EthNet]
[NUKE] Girls.S04E09.PROPER.720p.HDTV.x264-KILLERS [invalid.proper_credits.are.optional.per.ruleset_no.missing.dialog_i.imgur.com.bXDjGSO.jpg] [EthNet]
[UNNUKE] Girls.S04E09.HDTV.x264-ASAP [fine_no.missing.footage_credits.are.optional.per.ruleset] [EthNet]
[UNNUKE] Girls.S04E09.720p.HDTV.x264-IMMERSE [fine_no.missing.footage_credits.are.optional.per.ruleset] [EthNet]

[NUKE] Looking.S02E09.720p.HDTV.x264-IMMERSE [missing.credits.that.contain.unique.music.continuation.from.end.of.episode] [LocalNet]
[NUKE] Looking.S02E09.HDTV.x264-ASAP [missing.credits.that.contain.unique.music.continuation.from.end.of.episode] [LocalNet]
[UNNUKE] Looking.S02E09.720p.HDTV.x264-IMMERSE [fine_ruleset.only.specifies.that.unique.footage.must.be.left.in.credits_update.the.tv.ruleset.if.youd.like.music.included.too] [EthNet]
[UNNUKE] Looking.S02E09.HDTV.x264-ASAP [fine_ruleset.only.specifies.that.unique.footage.must.be.left.in.credits_update.the.tv.ruleset.if.youd.like.music.included.too] [EthNet]

The 2011_TV_X264_u2 state at line 171-173:
"Full end credits must be included if they contain show content or outtakes/bloopers."

Nowhere is the word footage used there.

Content = Video or Audio or Both
Content != Video Only

The rules do not have to be updated, they're extremely clear in the wording.
A unique audio track that begins in the last few seconds of the show that continues into the credits
is show content.
As such it must be included, and this proper along with any other of it's kind are valid.
(Here is the audio line, as you can see there is no dip or drop it is one continuous interrupted
playback > http://i62.tinypic.com/29pwy1z.png)

There have been many other propers AND repacks we can recall on this matter, all of them have remained unnuked.
If the credits rule is still ambiguous to people the fact that there's standing propers AND repacks
with this reason turns it into a precedent.

Otherwise we'd like to refer you to line 67-69 of 2011_TV_X264_u2:
"Severe audio drops resulting in one full missing word or otherwise the inability to understand
material dialogue is considered to be a technical flaw and may be propered"
The audio track that plays during the final seconds of IMMERSE's release and continues onto the
credits is cut off. It has dialogue, singing as such it's missing dialogue.

If other groups wont proper/repack for this we will.
We do not acknowledge EthNet nukes but we felt this needed explaining to those that do.
So they understand the validity of these propers.

Greetings to all the groups who choose quality, over speed and quantity!
Specifically 2HD, aAF, BAJSKORV, CTU, DIMENSION, EVOLVE, FEVER, FQM, KILLERS, KYR, LOL, SYS and YesTV.
Valediction to ASAP, CRiMSON, DOT, EXCELLENCE, IMMERSE, LMAO, OMiCRON, REMARKABLE, SWOLLED, W4F, XII and XOR.